With Stephon Marbury playing his former employers this week, who are excelling in his absence, there’s been a lot of talk about the possibility of him ever playing for a winning team. Most seem to think it isn’t possible.
And a lot of the talk is justified. The time he’s spent in Jersey and Phoenix hasn’t exactly been a clinic in a team-first mentality. He’s been a shoot-first player, there’s no doubt about that. And you look at the fact that both teams have had a lot more success as soon as he leaves, and it’s easy to label him a loser. But I’m not sure I buy it.
The Jersey teams he played for were awful. Just terrible. I don’t care was playing point for those teams, be it Stephon Marbury, Magic Johnson, or Moose from Arch Rivals, those teams weren’t going anywhere. Yes, they got better when Marbury left, but… adding Jason Kidd, Kenyon Martin, and Richard Jefferson didn’t hurt the Nets turnaround, either. They gave Marbury Keith Van Horn and told him to win games. Good luck with that.
And it’s a similar deal with Phoenix. They added Steve Nash, Amare Stoudamire made huge improvements, Shawn Marion’s gotten better, and don’t underestimate the contributions of guys like Joe Johnson and Q Richardson. And, of course, Mike D’Antoni. Yeah, teams have gotten better when Starbury left… but not because Starbury left.
As much as anyone, I believe a point guard should be there to distribute, to put other guys in good positions to score, and facilitate an offense. I don’t believe that Stephon Marbury can’t do that. He’s one of the league’s leaders in assists. When there’s a pass to be made, he’ll make it. But how many times in New Jersey, Phoenix, or New York has someone else been a better scoring option than Marbury?
This is not like Steve Francis refusing or being unable to get that ball into the post. It’s a case of “What’s the best option for the team?” Stephon Marbury shooting himself, or Stephon Marbury trying to set up Kurt Thomas or Tim Thomas? Shooting-first and passing second isn’t a good mentality for a point guard, but it’s not always born out of an ability to pass, but rather, a poorly constructed team. Does anyone think Steve Nash would be getting to the NBA Finals if he was the point guard of the Knicks this year?
I’ll take Stephon’s 8.5 assists per game. I’ll take his almost 3-to-1 assist/turnover ratio. And oh yeah, his 20 points per game.