
A couple days after seeing him do a surreal interview on Quite Frankly, Peter Vecsey is now starting up the Stephon Marbury trade rumors. That took what… four games?
I understand why the Knicks brought him in to begin with. The Knicks were losers, and if you’re going to be losers, you might as well have a really exciting point-scoring machine out there on the court. But now, they bring in Larry Brown, a sign that they want to be winners, and suddenly, the point guard position does not exist just for show. You need real, actual, basketball intelligence, and with Marbury, it just is not there.
The interview on Quite Frankly was a sight to behold. I will paraphrase.
“Stephon, who’s the best point guard in the league?”
“Me.”
“You’re better than Jason Kidd?”
“Yes.”
“You’re better than Steve Nash?”
“Yes.”
“Then why haven’t you ever won even a playoff series–”
“Let me cut you off right there, Stephen, because let me assure you I have an excuse for every situation, and the important thing to remember is that nothing has ever been my fault.”
“So it was your teammates’ fault?”
“Yes. My teammates have always been very bad, and I can’t even come close to comprehending the notion that point guards can make their teammates better. That one’s lost on me.”
“Who’s the best point guard in the league again?”
“ME! ME! ME! LOOK AT ME!”
(…and the New York crowd cheers wildly, because they just don’t know any better.)
He doesn’t get it. And at the age of 29, he probably isn’t going to start now, no matter how many times a day he calls Chauncey Billups. I don’t mind a guy being confident… I don’t even mind him saying he’s the best in the league, because sometimes a little swagger is a good thing. But when Marbury says it, it doesn’t come with a sense of “I’m going to outplay my opponent every night,” it comes with a sense of “I’m good, and my teammates aren’t, and if I had the supporting casts of those other guys, I’d be better than they are, because nothing is ever my fault.” Coming from Marbury, it doesn’t sound like confidence, but rather a refusal to be held accountable for any of his shortcomings. Sure, he’s never had a great set of teammates, but that shouldn’t keep him from making the ones he did have better… something he’s never done.
Just for kicks, I’m going to list all 30 of the league’s starting point guards, in order of how I’d select them if I had my choice of anyone in the league. I’m going to assume good health on all of them, and also take into consideration things like age and contract, etc. And just for the record, I wouldn’t be particularly excited about anyone outside of the Top 5.
1. Chauncey Billups
2. Tony Parker
3. Steve Nash
4. Jason Kidd
5. TJ Ford
6. Allen Iverson
7. Gilbert Arenas
8. Luke Ridnour
9. Kirk Hinrich
10. Mike Bibby
11. Joe Johnson
12. Sebastian Telfair
13. Baron Davis
14. Chris Paul
15. Delonte West
16. Andre Miller
17. Jamaal Tinsley
18. Steve Francis
19. Stephon Marbury
20. Mike James
21. Sam Cassell
22. Jason Terry
23. Marko Jaric
24. Brevin Knight
25. Damon Stoudamire
26. Jason Williams
27. Eric Snow
28. Smush Parker
29. Rafer Alston
30. Keith McLeod
And Marbury’s down there at #19… and I’m not even sure about having him that high. I could be talked into putting Mike James, Sam Cassell, and possibly Jason Terry ahead of him. Terry has his deficiencies, sure, but the difference is that he doesn’t think he’s the greatest basketball player in the universe, which works to his advantage.
Being a bad point guard is one thing, but it becomes that much worse when you have the attitude that you’re a good one. That’s Marbury.
(Gracias to joenetsfan.com for the image that I stole…)


